Reserve Bank rate cuts won’t stop house prices from falling

Advertisement

The Real Estate Institute of New Zealand’s (REINZ) House Price Index (HPI) reported a 16.7% decline nationwide from the market peak in 2021.

This has brought real inflation-adjusted housing prices back to pre-pandemic levels at the start of 2020.

NZ real house prices

The Reserve Bank of New Zealand commenced an interest rate easing cycle last month with an initial 0.25% cut to the official cash rate.

Advertisement

The Reserve Bank has also projected around 2.5% of rate cuts over a 2.5 year period:

Official cash rate

Historically, a reduction in the official cash has resulted in a rise in home prices owing to the resulting increase in borrowing capacity and mortgage serviceability.

Advertisement

However, ANZ’s latest New Zealand Property Focus projects that home values will fall further in the near term, even as mortgage interest rates continue to decline.

“Housing market momentum continued to weaken in August, with no sign as yet of a flurry of sales following the RBNZ’s first OCR cut last month”, ANZ notes.

“Sales volumes remained weak, while inventories on the market rose further, suggesting that house prices are likely to correct further over the coming months in order to clear the backlog“.

Advertisement
NZ housing indicators

ANZ cautions “that faster cuts from the RBNZ would likely occur in response to the economy underperforming the RBNZ’s already low expectations. In that scenario, lower interest rates may not be the boon for the housing market that many assume”.

“All up, there isn’t much to get excited about just yet for those anticipating a pick-up in the housing market from lower interest rates”, ANZ says.

Advertisement

“In fact, August’s data added further downside risk to our forecast for house prices to decline 1.0% y/y over 2024”.

ANZ house price forecasts

However, ANZ does acknowledge that “anecdotal evidence over recent weeks has pointed to a pick-up in activity”, pointing to the bounce in the auction clearance rate following the fall in interest rates.

The recent sharp moderation in net overseas migration is one factor working against a house price rebound.

Advertisement
NZ immigration

Large numbers of citizens are emigrating from New Zealand, replaced by poorer migrants from developing nations:

NZ citizen migration
Advertisement

As a result, annual New Zealand’s population growth is slowing, which will moderate housing demand:

NZ population growth

New Zealand’s economy is also stuck in a protracted per capita recession, and unemployment is rising fast.

Advertisement

Therefore, while I expect the housing market to respond to the cut in rates, the rebound will likely be sluggish.

About the author
Leith van Onselen is Chief Economist at the MB Fund and MB Super. He is also a co-founder of MacroBusiness. Leith has previously worked at the Australian Treasury, Victorian Treasury and Goldman Sachs.